I watch American Idol and am wondering why they put us through the shitty country week every year. It is never good! I like some country music, but it seems like people pick the same songs or artists every season and it gets really old. This time we had Garth Brooks, Carrie Underwood and Martina McBride night with a few other sprinkled in for good measure. While most of them were OK, there were a few stand outs to me.
Here were my thoughts on the performances.
Michael Sarver - Ain't Going Down Til the Sun Comes Up, Garth Brooks
He left me really disappointed. He seems like an nice guy, but I wasn't sure that he should have been in the top 13. Last night I finally realized I was right. You couldn't understand what the hell he was saying and he looked as though he was just fumbling around on the stage. Not good. He could be going home tonight.
Allison Irehata - Blame It On Your Heart, Patty Loveless
She sounded good again. I think that she could sing anything, including the alphabet (per Kara) because there is actually an alphabet song. Anyway, I didn't think it was a good as last week. I did think that it was a little boring in parts, but OK. I think she will be safe for now.
Kris Allen - To Make You Feel My Love, Garth Brooks
I thought he did very well this week. One of my favorites of the night. He did remind me a little of Jason Castro from last season, that's not a bad thing because Castro made it pretty far in the competition. Safe
Lil Rounds (Or Little as Simon called her) - Independence Day, Martina McBride
Ok, I thought this could be a little rough and it was. I was never as into her as the judges were. She has a good voice and is a "power" singer, this did not showcase that at all. She was flat the beginning of the song and the tempo seemed off. NOt a good performance or choice of song so she could be in trouble.
Adam Lambert - Ring of Fire, Johnny Cash
I thought this was just awesome! Adam is not and never will be a country singer and he showed that tonight. The judges had mixed reviews. Randy seemed to really like it calling it current, young, fresh and like Nine Inch Nails which I didn't totally understand. Kara said it left her confused and kinda happy, Paula rambled on and on (she seemed especially stoned tonight) and Simon called it trash. It was also awkward and funny to see the reaction that Randy Travis had. He was not amused by this version and you could tell he hated it. I agree with both Randy and Kara. It was strange, but I liked it. He is for sure one of the most unique artists on the show, knows who he is and goes for it! Did the rest of America like it, I hope so!
cott McIntyre - Wild Angels, Martina McBride
Even though the judges seem to think Scott is a genius, I really don't see it. I think he is good on the piano, but just can't get into his singing. Don't know why. I thought he did OK tonight and will probably be safe.
Alexis Grace - Jolene, Dolly Parton
I thought this again, like most of the night, was just OK. She sounded alright. Made it a little too bluesy and jazzy. Not a fan of the song to begin with and I actually think I fast-forwarded through some of it. Maybe going home.
Gokey - Jesus Take the Wheel, Carrie Underwood
Oh, the horror of the outfit. What in the hell was he wearing! That was the first bad part. The versus of the song were not so good. I like him, I think he is normally a good singer, but this was out of key and just bad. The chorus was better, but was not feeling the Gokey tonight. It could be a wake up call for him to be in the bottom 2. I don't think it will happen because he is too popular, but it could be a good wake up call.
Anoop Dogg - You Are Always On My Mind, Willie Nelson
I think this is one of Anoops best performances in the whole competition to date. This is the way I remeber him sounding before his Bobby Brown and Michael Jackson week. One of my favorites of the night. Hopefully he'll get the votes he needs to stay in the competition after this performance.
Megan Joy Cockery - Walkin After Midnight, Patsy Cline
Last week was just awful for her and I expected this week to be the same. However, she wasn't completely shitty. She did better than I anticipated. I am still not a fan. She does this really awkward dance on stage everytime she sings and picks the oldest song 2 weeks in a row. I think she should be the one to go home this week, but we'll see.
Matt Giraud - So Small, Carrie Underwood
I thought the beginning was a little rough, but he picked it up in the middle and the end. Overall I thought he did a pretty good job. I liked him better last week, but he is a good singer and pianist. I think that he will get enough votes and will be safe this week.
Favorites: Kris Allen, Adam Lambert and Anoop
In Trouble: Michael Sarver, Lil Rounds and Megan Joy